Rusty Williams
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Counterfactual and alternative histories

During my hiatus from this blog, I had a chance to catch up on some reading.

I read a lot of fiction, but I’d never read Harry Turtledove’s counterfactual Civil War series. I started with The Guns of the South, the first book in the series. I lasted 25 pages before I put the book down for good.

A friend said the Gingrich/Forstchen trilogy was better. Maybe it was. I got through 40 pages of Gettysburg before giving up.

The problem is not with the books; bazillions of people have enjoyed them. The problem is my inability to stay “in the moment” when the story begins to diverge from history as I know it. I can immerse myself in the most outrageous thriller fiction—Jack Reacher, anyone?—and swim the channel without a second thought. But put an AK-47 on a Civil War battlefield and I sink like a rock.

Why can’t I get into these? I’ve enjoyed counterfactual or alternate history in the past. (How the South Won the Civil War thrilled me as a kid, and I’ve read and reread most of the What If? essays collected by Robert Cowley.) Have I learned too much about the Civil War to be able to accept these counter-historical tales? Am I subconsciously resisting messing up my head with facts that aren’t facts?

What’s been your experience with counterfactual and alternative histories?

Contact me

I’m available for book signings and speaking engagements, or if you just want to connect.


I hate spam as much as you do and will never sell your information. What I will do is send news about upcoming events, and book release dates to your inbox.  You can unsubscribe at any time. 

Latest Posts

Find Your Way

To help me explain the importance of Texas and Oklahoma toll bridges in the Red River Bridge War, I had to explain the development of

Read More »

A Fraught Month

For many Americans, 1931 marked the depth of the Great Depression, with high unemployment, bank failures, evictions, and little help from Washington. State governors did

Read More »

It’s the Pits

Before backyard pools, municipal swimming pools, and water parks, many Dallasites went for summer dips in the water-filled gravel pits surrounding town. The pits had

Read More »

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay in touch!

Sign up to receive my latest blog posts and hear about new release dates and speaking engagements.